A place for peculiar ideas.

Research article / 4 minute read

WO2022067093: Rice's 2020 Ultrafast Flash Joule Heating Filing and Its Reach into Metal Recovery, Carbides and Ceramics

WO2022067093 is an international (PCT) patent application titled "Ultrafast flash Joule heating synthesis methods and systems for performing same". Its two listed inventors are James M. Tour (James M. Tour) and Bing Deng (Bing Deng), and William Marsh Rice University (Rice University) is named as both original and current assignee. In this dossier it marks the point where Flash Joule Heating (FJH) stopped being only a way to make graphene and began to be patented for recovering metals from waste and for making carbides and ceramics. The Google Patents record shows this through its classification codes and its family. The record does not include an abstract or any claim text, so what the application actually claims cannot be read from it.

Dates and filing route

The record gives a priority date of 24 September 2020, taken from US provisional application 63/082,592, which was filed that same day. The PCT application, PCT/US2021/052043, was filed on 24 September 2021. It appeared in three versions: WO2022067093A2 on 31 March 2022, A3 on 12 May 2022, and A9 on 29 December 2022. Google lists the international application itself as "Ceased" and gives 24 March 2023 as an anticipated expiration date. That status covers only the PCT stage. On the same filing day the application was used as the priority basis for national and regional filings: US18/246,451 (published as US20230357885A1), AU2021350022A1, CN202180078294.8 (now CN116390819B), EP21844823.1 (EP4217310A2) and CA3193826A1. The legal-events table shows entry into the Canadian, European and Australian phases in 2023, and non-entry into Germany. Google adds that its status, date and assignee entries are assumptions, not legal conclusions.

Four sibling filings on one day

On 24 September 2020 Rice filed four PCT applications with the same priority date, and the record lists all of them: PCT/US2021/052070 (WO2022067111), PCT/US2021/052030 (WO2022067085), this application (PCT/US2021/052043), and PCT/US2021/052057 (WO2022067102). The last one has a narrower title, covering methods "for the preparation of corundum nanoparticles", which means alpha-alumina. All four are marked ceased at the international stage. The country-status table also shows family members in Japan (JP7843049B2, which Google lists as active), Korea (KR20230097003A) and a second Chinese grant (CN116406320B). These belong to the wider family, and it is not clear from the record that they descend from this particular PCT application.

What the classifications indicate

With no abstract or claims available, the classification codes are the best guide to the application's subject matter. They cover several fields:

  • Metal recovery and waste. Codes for recovering noble metals from manufactured products such as printed circuit boards, by both dry and wet processes. Others cover rare-earth metals, pretreatment of scrap, acid leaching, and thermal treatment of solid waste, with sub-tags for electronic waste, food waste and plastic waste.
  • Carbides. Titanium carbide, tungsten or molybdenum carbides, silicon carbide and boron carbide, plus refractory-metal carbide ceramics.
  • Oxides and ceramics. Aluminium oxide including transition aluminas, fine ceramics, molybdenum oxides, and powder treatment by flame, plasma or pyrolysis.
  • Powders and characterisation. Making metallic powders by physical and chemical routes, together with indexing codes for crystallite size, XRD and XPS/EDX data, TEM imaging, surface area, pore diameter, submicron and sub-100 nm particle sizes, and heating and cooling rates.

Patent offices assign these codes to describe a document's subject matter. They are not findings, and nothing in them shows which metals, carbides or yields the application demonstrates.

Lineage: what it cites and what cites it

The record lists one patent citation: Rice's earlier WO2020051000A1, "Flash joule heating synthesis method and compositions thereof" (priority 5 September 2018). It has the same title and the same 5 September 2018 priority date as the granted US flash graphene patent discussed in The Granted Flash Graphene Patent (US12054391B2): What Rice University Claimed for Pulse-Heated Carbon. The one non-patent citation is Wang Chengwei et al., "A general method to synthesize and sinter bulk ceramics in seconds", Science vol. 368, no. 6490 (1 May 2020), pp. 521–526. Its subject overlaps with Flash Sintering (Field-Assisted Sintering). The examiners' family citations also include older metal-reclamation patents, for example Mkr, Inc.'s 1988 "Reclamation of metals by flash direct reduction" and plasma-arc recovery of platinum-group metals.

Google lists 22 citing families. The Rice filings among them are on electrothermal chlorination for selective metal recovery, heavy-metal-reduced post-industrial waste in cementitious materials, flash production of 1D carbon and boron nitride nanomaterials, recovery and reuse of conductive additives, and a 2023 filing (WO2025072466A2) that reuses this application's title. The rest include Honeywell (contact Joule heating for coatings), Universal Matter Inc. (graphene production), and many Chinese institutions. Their subjects include Joule-heat detoxification of incineration fly ash, iron-doped graphene from red mud, graphene from spent battery anode graphite, high-entropy carbides and alloys, and pretreatment of deep-sea polymetallic nodules.

What the record does and does not establish

The record shows who filed, when, under which codes, and how widely the family spread. It does not include process parameters, recovery percentages, product purities or experimental data, so it gives no basis for judging whether the methods work (see Patent as Evidence). Being cited 22 times shows that later filers and examiners treated the application as relevant prior art, not that its results were confirmed. Readers looking for actual reported figures on remediation and recovery should go to Environmental Remediation by Flash Joule Heating and Flash Joule Heating Claims vs. Evidence: The Dossier's Figures and the Absence of Independent Verification.

Source notes & attribution
  1. https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2022067093A3/en