Most of this dossier's material on Eduard "Billy" Meier is about whether his photographs could have been faked. This article, by the British sceptic Anthony Wharton of St Helens and published by the NZ Skeptics, approaches that question by trying to fake them. Wharton reports that he built small saucer models and photographed them in the hope of matching Meier's pictures. He also gathers a set of other objections: a supposedly recurring miniature tree, a 1970s computer analysis by Ground Saucer Watch, and a metallurgist's reading of one of Meier's metal samples. The piece is openly polemical. Wharton frames it as a fresh look at the case for Meier's 85th birthday, and it includes an update dated 30 January 2022.
What Wharton set out to test
The stated trigger was a claim by Michael Horn, Meier's authorised American media representative. As Wharton reports it, Horn said the photographs could not be reproduced without millions of dollars or Hollywood special-effects facilities. That claim echoes an estimate in Gary Kinder's defence of Light Years (Gary Kinder's Defence of Light Years: The Meier Case, the Withheld Evidence and the Experts Consulted). There, special-effects director Wally Gentleman put each of Meier's films at 15 assistants, $30,000 of studio work and $50,000 of equipment.
The replications
Wharton says his first attempt dates from 2004: small model saucers, dangled by line from a rod and photographed on 35mm film, with the results posted on Flickr. Horn and Meier then challenged him over the wedding cake photograph, which they present as a huge spacecraft above Meier's van. In response he photographed a saucer model close to a 35mm film camera, framed above distant large vehicles. He calls his results almost identical to Meier's. The principle he invokes is forced perspective. A small object near the lens can look like a large object far away. He adds a 2022 black-and-white photograph of a model hung on strings.
What these replications show is narrower than Wharton claims. They show that pictures of the same general kind can be made cheaply, which answers Horn's argument about cost. They do not show how any particular Meier picture was made. The article gives no camera settings, no model dimensions and no side-by-side measurement against Meier's frames, and the comparison photographs live on external sites. Wharton nonetheless calls the replication "conclusive proof".
The tree, the van and the drum lid
Much of the article relies on Victor Gibbs (1925–2017), who contacted Wharton by email in 2009. Gibbs had spent 30 years in gardening and forestry work and many years in the Royal Air Force. On the basis of that experience he judged that a tree appearing in several Meier films and photographs was a miniature, perhaps a tabletop Christmas tree as small as 30 inches. Wharton adds that the same-looking tree turns up in images he says were taken years apart and in different places. By his account, Meier and Horn answered that the resemblance was coincidence and that the real trees stood 40 to 50 feet tall or more.
Gibbs also listed visual cues that he took to mean small, close objects:
- edges too crisp for distant aerial objects
- no atmospheric haze around the craft
- undersides that are very dark
- no ground shadow from the craft, although the van casts one
Wharton links the wedding cake craft to the lid of a Harcostar Universal Container, of which he says several were photographed in a storage room at FIGU, Meier's organisation. He also points to carpet tacks on the model, one of which he says lies loose on its surface. For the 1976 Hasenbol picture, he says he simply turned the photograph into a negative image, and that this shows the craft in front of the tree, not behind its branches. For the van photograph, he says he both brightened the image and made a negative, and that the craft again appears in front of the foliage. The Hasenbol claim contradicts Stevens's statement (The Stevens–Dilettoso Photo Analysis of the Meier Pictures: Methods, Film Readings and the 'No Fraud' Verdict) that the Hasenbol craft hovered about 100 yards beyond a tree. Wharton's own analysis was done on what he describes as very low-quality images. He says Meier refused his request for high-resolution versions.
Ground Saucer Watch and the metal sample
The most specific measurement-type claim in the article is not Wharton's own. He cites Ground Saucer Watch's 1970s computer analysis of a Type-4 craft that Meier photographed over Mount Auruti, Switzerland, on 29 March 1976. Ground Saucer Watch reported a linear structure above the craft, which Wharton reads as a string or rod. A focus study also put the object close to the camera and about 8 inches (20 centimetres) across, against Meier's figure of 23 feet (7 metres). Wharton displays the two computer-enhanced images of the Mount Auruti photograph and quotes the group's findings, including its verdict that the analysed photographs "can be duplicated with a basic camera and darkroom equipment". Beyond the size estimate, he gives no measurements, method or numerical data. Kinder, for his part, had quoted Bill Moore dismissing Ground Saucer Watch's Bill Spaulding, so the authority of this analysis is itself disputed within the dossier.
On the metal, Wharton quotes page 214 of the 2001 book And Yet…They Fly!. According to that book, a University of Arizona metallurgist identified a fragment as an ordinary cookware-grade metal, a cheap cast alloy of the kind used for tin soldiers. That contrasts with the statement Kinder attributes to Marcel Vogel of IBM, that the sample could not be made with known technology. The metallurgist is unnamed and no analysis is given. Wharton says he has asked for a sample for 18 years without receiving one.
Other allegations
Wharton also reports that photographs of the alleged women Asket and Nera were taken from a television screen showing Dean Martin show dancers. He says a flying-dinosaur picture came from a book, and he suggests that "Alena" with a laser gun is Meier or his ex-wife Popi in costume. A crop-circle researcher he consulted in 2005 put Meier's landing circles at no more than 15 inches across, not the more than 2 metres (over 6 feet) Meier claimed; Kinder's six-foot figure matches that claim. Wharton also says the vanishing-craft films are jump cuts, and he links a video that he says shows Popi Meier, Meier's ex-wife, admitting the case is a hoax. These are assertions, backed mainly by links to videos and images.
What the article does and does not establish
The article's contribution to the dossier is a sceptic's hands-on attempt to reproduce the Meier pictures, which sits against the pro-authenticity pages. It shows that the visual effect of the Meier pictures does not require studio resources. Its stronger conclusions do not follow from that. A successful imitation does not prove the originals were made the same way, and Wharton's insistence that it proves a hoax overstates his own work. His demand that Meier and Horn pay him $1,000,000 in damages shows how adversarial the piece is. The tree, shadow and haze arguments are interpretive. Ground Saucer Watch's 8-inch estimate and the metallurgist's finding are relayed second-hand, as are the expert opinions Kinder relays on the other side. For the investigators' pro-authenticity case, see The Stevens–Dilettoso Photo Analysis of the Meier Pictures: Methods, Film Readings and the 'No Fraud' Verdict; for the overall claim set, Pleiades Embassy Claims vs. Evidence: The Contactee Account and Its Artifacts and Pleiadian Contact Narrative.
Source notes & attribution
- https://skeptics.nz/latest/ufos-the-camera-does-not-lie