The floating aluminium tubes at the centre of this dossier depend on air staying where it was trapped (see Air-Trapping Buoyancy (Plastron-Based Flotation)). This open-access review by Zhao Qing Tang, Tongfei Tian, Paul J Molino, Alex Skvortsov, Dong Ruan, Jie Ding and Yali Li looks at the same problem from the marine-engineering side. It was received on 27 October 2023, revised on 30 December 2023 and collected in the April 2024 issue. It does not discuss Guo's tubes. Its value here is that it gathers published figures on how long underwater air layers last, and it is openly sceptical about how most of those figures were obtained.
What the review sets out to do
The authors survey superhydrophobic surfaces intended for ships, pipelines, underwater robots and sensors, where the hoped-for benefits are lower drag, less biofouling and less corrosion. Their abstract names two things that keep these coatings out of wide commercial use: the coatings are not durable enough, and the trapped air layer (the plastron) does not stay stable during long submersion. They add that pressure, flow and temperature make the problem harder. Much of the review covers fabrication: nanomaterial coatings, magnetically switchable textures, 3D-printed copies of the floating fern Salvinia molesta, and machine-learning design tools. For this dossier, the important part is the section on plastron durability.
The mechanism, and why it fails
The review uses the standard wetting models. A surface holding air between its rough features is in the Cassie-Baxter state. One that water has fully flooded is in the Wenzel state. The authors stress that the Cassie-Baxter state is fragile: a change in either the roughness or the surface chemistry can tip it into the Wenzel state. Underwater, they identify the main threat to plastron lifetime as a wetting transition driven by hydrostatic pressure. This happens quickly once water pressure exceeds the capillary pressure and the pressure of the trapped air. Gas diffusion, flow shear and suspended particles add to the damage. Physical wear is a separate problem: crushing the micro/nanostructures removes the air pockets, and long exposure can change the surface chemistry.
The review's main design model is the Salvinia leaf. Its eggbeater-shaped hairs have water-attracting tips that pin the air–water boundary, and the review says this structure can hold air underwater "for up to several weeks or longer".
What was actually measured
The review collects reported lifetimes from many groups. All figures below are those studies' results as the review reports them. The review did not repeat any of the experiments.
| Study (as cited) | Surface | Reported result | Test conditions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tang et al. (cited study, water-strider-inspired fibres) | micrometre-scale conical fibre array | air pocket held ≈41 days (vs ≈10 and ≈2 days for comparison arrays) | 13 cm liquid depth |
| Wu et al. | triple-layer candle-soot coating | superhydrophobic for 46, 38 and 27 days | 20 cm (≈1.96 kPa), 80 cm (≈7.84 kPa), 140 cm (≈13.72 kPa) |
| Wu et al. | same, field test | held for more than 35 days of a 50-day test | natural lake, 20 cm depth |
| Ranjan et al. | candle-soot coating on porous silicon | silvery plastron visible after 30 days | 10 cm of tap water |
| Smyrnakis et al. | plasma-textured PMMA | stable air layer for at least 60 days | a few centimetres |
| Martinez-Gomez et al. | PDMS-modified nano-silica | still water-repellent after six months, but no in-situ air shine seen | 2 cm of water |
| Tricinci et al. | synthetic Salvinia replica | stable Cassie-Baxter state | up to 4 atm |
| Rawlinson et al. | void-rich surface with pulsed gas injection | plastron life extended from 4.8 to 29 days | still water |
| Zhao et al. | sparse silica "respiratory skin" | plastron unstable at 25 kPa, gone at 40 kPa | microscope observation under pressure |
The deepest result in the table, Wu et al.'s 27 days at 140 cm, is still shallow by marine standards. The Zhao et al. pressure figures apply to one surface type, after its air layer had been restored by gas injection. They are not a general limit for every texture. The review's text gives a 2 cm water column for the Martinez-Gomez test, while its figure caption says 20 cm.
How the review judges this evidence
The authors are critical of their own field's methods. They object to Wu et al.'s depth data because samples were taken out of the water to measure contact angle, so the result does not show whether the plastron was really present underwater. They say the six-month figure does not show a surviving air layer, since the silvery shine was not seen in place. They say centimetre-deep tank tests do not represent real air diffusion or flow. Their verdict is that, in reported results, plastron failure "seems inevitable". They also say testing conditions usually do not match real exposure, and that inconsistent test methods prevent fair comparisons between coatings.
The review names two approaches it considers stronger. The first is real-time measurement of air-layer thickness by white light reflectance spectroscopy (Smyrnakis et al.). The second is a field test by Yu et al., which mounted samples under a 13-foot motorboat in brackish water at a sea mouth. That test monitored gas saturation and shear at boat speeds of 2 to 7.2 m s⁻¹, and found that samples with a nanograss texture lost less air at high speed. Because failure appears unavoidable, the review presents regeneration as the practical answer: injecting gas can restore the air layer within about 5 s. The drawback, in the review's account, is that this needs a continuous external air supply.
How it bears on the tube claims
The tube material claims no loss of buoyancy over weeks in rough conditions (see Superhydrophobic Metallic Tubes Claims vs. Evidence: The Press Framing, the Paper Abstract and the Patent Abstracts). This review does not test that claim. It does provide a benchmark. Across the surfaces it covers, reported lifetimes run from days to a few months, mostly at depths of centimetres. The longest figures, 60 days (Smyrnakis et al.) and six months (Martinez-Gomez et al.), both come from tests only centimetres deep, and in the six-month case no air layer was seen in place underwater. Several are judged by an indirect method that the authors themselves distrust. None of the surfaces in the review holds air indefinitely without regeneration.
The comparison has limits. A tube holds a large air pocket behind a divider. Losing that pocket may depend on different physics from losing a thin film held in surface texture. The review's numbers therefore set the standard of evidence a long-flotation claim would need to meet: in-situ observation, realistic depth, flow, and seawater. They do not by themselves refute the tube claim. The dissolution mechanism behind this kind of slow loss is examined in more detail in How Long Does an Underwater Air Layer Last? Dissolved-Gas Saturation and Texture Geometry on 3D-Printed Superhydrophobic Posts (Jilan, Solano-Calderon and Mohammadshahi, 2025), and the role of layered texture in Hierarchical Micro/Nanoscale Surface Texturing.
Reference
Tang, Z. Q., Tian, T., Molino, P. J., Skvortsov, A., Ruan, D., Ding, J. and Li, Y. "Recent Advances in Superhydrophobic Materials Development for Maritime Applications." 2024. Open access at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11040384/
Source notes & attribution
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11040384/