A place for peculiar ideas.

Research article / 5 minute read

Motion in the Lowest-Energy State: Shapere and Wilczek's Classical Time Crystals (2012)

"Classical Time Crystals" is a short theoretical paper by Alfred Shapere (University of Kentucky) and Frank Wilczek (MIT), posted to arXiv as 1202.2537 (the version discussed here is v2, dated 12 July 2012). It is the classical companion to Wilczek's quantum proposal (arXiv:1202.2359), which the dossier's Time Crystal page treats as the origin of the idea. Where the quantum paper asks about ground states of quantum systems, this one asks a classical question: can an ordinary, time-independent classical system that conserves energy be in motion when it has the least energy it can possibly have?

The question and why it seems absurd

The authors frame the issue as Spontaneous Time-Translation Symmetry Breaking. If the lowest-energy solution of time-symmetric equations moves, the solution has less symmetry than the laws that produce it. For an angular variable, the motion would be periodic, so continuous time symmetry would be reduced to a discrete one, the temporal counterpart of atoms repeating in space. The paper notes that the phrase "time crystal" had already been applied to periodic phenomena elsewhere, citing A. Winfree's work on biological rhythms.

The paper is candid about two objections. What they are looking for, the authors concede, seems "perilously close to perpetual motion". And if energy is conserved, a moving minimum-energy state requires the energy to reach its minimum along an entire curve of positions and velocities rather than at one isolated point, which is not what one generically expects.

Easy in space, fragile in time

The authors start with something unproblematic: it is simple to write potentials for an angular field in which the cheapest configuration has a nonzero spatial slope, so the field winds through space and spatial translation symmetry breaks. They then try swapping the spatial slope for a velocity. One version collapses: its energy is lowest at zero velocity. The other, with a negative quadratic and a positive quartic term in the velocity, survives, its energy minimised at a nonzero speed.

Rewriting the same models in Hamiltonian form, with momentum in place of the slope, kills the effect entirely. The paper argues this is general: for a smooth Hamiltonian, the energy minimum sits where all its gradients vanish, which by Hamilton's equations means nothing moves. The escape is that the surviving Lagrangian cannot be smoothly turned into a Hamiltonian. Energy becomes a multivalued function of momentum with cusps exactly at the moving minima, and the paper describes a swallowtail catastrophe appearing as a coupling constant passes through zero. At a cusp the usual rule that the gradient vanishes at a minimum does not apply. The price is that, at the minimum, the coefficient of acceleration in the equations of motion vanishes, so the equations alone no longer determine what happens next.

Turning points and the "brick wall"

Adding a potential energy creates a conflict: the potential prefers a fixed position, the kinetic term prefers motion. The paper's analysis finds that the system can hit a point where it must reverse instantly, with the speed flipping sign and momentum jumping, which the authors compare to bouncing off a wall held by an infinitely massive source. Near the bottom of a simple well, the trajectories ricochet back and forth at nearly constant speed. The authors call these "brick wall" solutions.

To avoid such singular behaviour they build a family they call the fgh model, in which the Lagrangian is a quartic-plus-quadratic polynomial in velocity with position-dependent coefficients. By tuning those coefficients, they show that any orbit whose velocity never changes sign can be made the stable lowest-energy motion of a reasonably simple Lagrangian. Motions that do reverse direction exist, but cost more energy than the one-way minimal orbit. If the coefficients are not tuned, the models run smoothly at high energy but can become singular at low energy, which the authors acknowledge is the reverse of the usual effective-field-theory philosophy, though they liken it to perturbative QCD.

Symmetry makes it natural: the double sombrero

A further section asks how energy could be naturally constant along an orbit. The answer offered is symmetry: if every point on the orbit is related to the others by a symmetry, none is preferred. The "double sombrero" model pairs a sombrero-shaped kinetic term with a sombrero-shaped potential for two fields. Its lowest-energy state, the paper reports, is circular motion around the potential's trough at constant speed.

Written in polar form, the steadily rotating phase carries a uniform, nonzero density of the conserved charge associated with the broken rotation symmetry; the link between symmetries and conserved quantities is the subject of Noether's Theorem. The authors draw two consequences: a body cooled into this state from a symmetric environment would have to radiate a balancing charge; and although time translation and phase rotation are each broken, a combination of the two leaves the motion unchanged, a residual "locked" symmetry that can be handled in a rotating frame with an effective chemical potential.

A travelling density wave

The final constructions add spatial structure. A potential that favours gradients makes the field's magnitude vary sinusoidally in space, a charge density wave. With an extra term coupling time and space derivatives, the minimum becomes a wave sliding along at speed v. The paper states that this breaks spatial translation, time translation and time reversal, leaving only a combined discrete time-space-charge symmetry, and calls the result a tangible form of time dependence. In the authors' reading, the steady circling of the field's internal phase has turned into a wave that moves through ordinary space. The dossier groups related ideas about order that repeats in both space and time under Space-Time Crystal; this travelling wave is a purely theoretical example of that kind of pattern.

Quantum hints and a relativistic aside

On quantisation the paper is speculative. The authors see nothing that plainly rules out quantum versions of these models, but they offer no proof that such versions exist. They note that a multivalued Hamiltonian means momentum alone cannot label states, and defer that problem to later work on branched quantization. A semiclassical (Bohr–Sommerfeld) argument suggests quantisation could push the ground state onto a slightly higher orbit that avoids the singular region. A closing note argues that relativistic models with a quartic term have energy unbounded below, whereas a sextic leading term can keep energy positive, and suggests this could constrain earlier cosmological models by Armendariz-Picon, Damour and Mukhanov (1999) and Arkani-Hamed and colleagues (2004).

What the paper does and does not establish

The paper is pure theory: it presents mathematical models, not measurements or a proposed apparatus. The authors themselves acknowledge that their density-wave construction is a single, purpose-built example. It shows that suitably chosen Lagrangians have moving minimum-energy solutions; it does not show that any real material is described by them, and it leaves the existence of quantum versions open. Its systems are undriven and time-independent, which distinguishes them from the periodically driven Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) experiments and from the driven liquid-crystal devices described in the dossier's patent applications. The later theoretical objections recorded under Watanabe–Oshikawa No-Go Statement postdate this paper and are not addressed in it.

Source notes & attribution
  1. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1202.2537